Doubts greet Philippines-China coastguard deal to calm disputed waters

SCMP | Oct. 19, 2025, 8 p.m. | Original
VID

A Chinese coastguard ship (right) fires a water cannon at a Philippine vessel near the Philippine-occupied Thitu Island in the South China Sea on October 12. Photo: Philippine coastguard/AP

Manila and Beijing are working on a coastguard cooperation pact as part of efforts to manage recurring flashpoints in the disputed South China Sea , but observers say the step may not be enough to prevent conflict or build lasting trust.

Department of Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro told the Senate on Tuesday that the proposed plan aimed to “reach a conclusion … an MOU for them [coastguards] on certain issues that involve both sides”.

Lazaro hoped that the agreement would boost cooperation and reduce confrontation in the hotly contested waterway, where the Philippines has in the past accused the Chinese coastguard of harassing its ships, including firing water cannons at them.

In the latest incident on October 12, a fisheries bureau vessel suffered “minor structural damage” after it was reportedly rammed by a Chinese coastguard ship while delivering aid to fishermen near Thitu, or Pag-asa Island, said Jay Tarriela, a spokesman for the Philippine coastguard.

Beijing claims sovereignty over almost the entirety of the South China Sea – where the Philippines and several other nations have competing claims – and has rejected a 2016 international ruling that ruled in favour of Manila and found China’s assertions have no legal basis.

Analysts backed the move but warned it could fall short of achieving the desired results.

Choose your listening speed

Get through articles 2x faster

2 dead after cargo plane slides off Hong Kong runway, partly lands in sea Hong Kong exchange sees further growth ahead for record ETF market